Dark chocolate (KB Shimmer’s holographic brown, Oh My Ganache) dripping with ooey gooey caramel (Whimsical Ideas by Pam’s Caramellow.) Or possibly peanut butter. Pick your Valentine’s Day poison! Unless of course you’re allergic to peanuts, in which case the peanut butter is actual poison, so perhaps best to stick with the caramel? Well, no matter how you’re celebrating or what you’re eating, Happy Valentine’s Day, friends!
Finger Candy 
If peanut butter makes it a Reese’s Cups polish, I choose that!
So not the same thing, but I thought Burger King put out a special edition polish that looked and smelled like ketchup. Yikes!